Beyond Paradigms: Analytic Eclecticism in the Study of World by Rudra Sil

By Rudra Sil

Whereas paradigm-bound study has generated robust insights in diplomacy, it has fostered a tunnel imaginative and prescient that hinders growth and widens the chasm among thought and coverage. during this vital new booklet, Sil and Katzenstein draw upon fresh scholarship to demonstrate some great benefits of a extra pragmatic and eclectic sort of study.

Show description

Read Online or Download Beyond Paradigms: Analytic Eclecticism in the Study of World Politics PDF

Similar public policy books

China and Globalization: The Social, Economic and Political Transformation of Chinese Society (Global Realities)

Choice notable educational name 2009!

In its quarter-century-long shift from communism to capitalism, China has remodeled itself from a desperately negative kingdom right into a kingdom with one of many fastest-growing and biggest economies on the earth. Doug Guthrie examines the reforms riding the industrial genesis during this compact and hugely readable advent to modern China. He highlights the social, cultural and political components fostering this progressive switch and interweaves a huge structural research with a attention of social alterations on the micro and macro levels.

In this new, revised variation writer Guthrie updates his tale on sleek China and offers the most recent authoritative information and examples from present occasions to chart the place this dynamically altering society is headed and what the most probably results for the remainder of the realm will be.

Black Conservative Intellectuals in Modern America

Within the final 3 many years, a model of black conservatism espoused via a debatable team of African American intellectuals has turn into a fixture within the nation's political panorama, its proponents having formed coverage debates over one of the most urgent concerns that confront modern American society.

The Geography of International Terrorism: An Introduction to Spaces and Places of Violent Non-State Groups

Whereas geography isn't the in simple terms issue to form human habit, its impression on terrorists’ motivations, behaviors, suggestions, and actions is a chief attention in realizing terrorism. Taking a unique technique than many different books on terrorism, The Geography of foreign Terrorism: An advent to areas and locations of Violent Non-State teams offers an available, cross-disciplinary method of dealing with terrorism on an international scale.

The Gendered Effects of Electoral Institutions: Political Engagement and Participation

In such a lot nations worldwide, girls proceed to lag in the back of males in an array of political orientations and actions. knowing why this is often the case and why a few international locations were extra profitable than others at moderating gender gaps in political involvement is relevant for generating more suitable and extra consultant democracies.

Extra resources for Beyond Paradigms: Analytic Eclecticism in the Study of World Politics

Sample text

A strong proponent of liberalism, Andrew Moravcsik (2008), has also called for de-emphasizing theoretical parsimony and ontological consistency in order to facilitate synthetic analyses featuring causal factors drawn from different theories. Moravcsik (2003, p. 132) notes: The complexity of most large events in world politics precludes plausible unicausal explanations. The outbreak of World Wars I and II, the emergence of international human rights norms, and the evolution of the European Union, for example, are surely important enough events to merit comprehensive explanation even at the expense of theoretical parsimony.

Even when it is not offering explicit policy prescriptions, eclectic scholarship should have some clear implications for some set of policy debates or salient normative concerns that enmesh leaders, public intellectuals, and other actors in a given political setting. ’ Chapter 2 elaborates on this point in the context of the ‘pragmatist turn’ in international relations scholarship. g. g. g. g. Lindblom and Cohen 1979; Nye 2009). Our conceptualization of eclectic scholarship is distinctive in that it seeks to bridge all of these concerns, linking a pragmatist orientation towards the production of useful knowledge to problem-driven research aimed at a better understanding of real-world phenomena and to mid-range causal accounts that draw upon mechanisms and processes normally analyzed in isolation within separate paradigms.

For two reasons, however, we do not believe that the problem is insurmountable. First, the incommensurability thesis is most compelling when it comes to uniform criteria for evaluating diverse theories; it is much less constraining when it comes to integrating elements from these theories. Donald Davidson (1974) and Hilary Putnam (1981) have both noted that the incommensurability thesis would be valid only if it were completely impossible to translate terms expressed in the language of one theoretical scheme into the language of another.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.88 of 5 – based on 43 votes